These boots are pretty great! Just bought these boots a week or two ago and I've already wore them multiple times due to the comfort and purpose! Keep my feet warm and dry! I love the lining to these boots as well. I do agree though that they could use a little more support in the soles. They do run slightly big, but I'm not sure if they are slightly big enough to order a size down. Overall I'd say these were a good purchase! Can't wait to wear them in the snow!!