I just bought two pairs of Pine. I love the shoes and they look great. However, sizing is not consistent. The blue pair is wider and what I need for my square feet. The tan pair are narrower in the front toe area, and the left shoe is smaller than the right. My daughter is breaking these in for me and hopefully they will stretch out a bit. I have two pairs of Chai boots, the whiskey pair are tighter than the black so this is not an isolated issue. I have difficulty with cute shoes fitting my wide feet and have several pairs of Jambu /JSport- some styles have gotten narrower over the years, but I keep buying them!